YY markYY Method™ · Home Edition v2.3
MethodViolinCases & ADRsBen Chan
← Case Studies/Case #012/C12-040
C12-040DecidedDefensive Judgment and First ResponseCross-cutting2026-07-17

Introduce Approved Compacts

Ben’s reviewed lived-experience judgments should be encoded in bounded knowledge units.

Freshness
Permanent

Permanent. Revisit if launch evidence, teacher feedback, user behavior, corpus quality, or safety review materially changes this decision.

#defensive-judgment#introduce#violin-stand-partner

Capture

Ben’s reviewed lived-experience judgments should be encoded in bounded knowledge units.

Why

A broad blueprint could not safely contain every domain judgment.

The blueprint should remain stable while Approved Compacts grow.

The moat is not merely the concept of a Compact. It is:

Why-Not

Production Compacts, exact conditions, edge cases, thresholds, and mappings.


Commit

Decision: Ben’s reviewed lived-experience judgments should be encoded in bounded knowledge units.

The decision becomes a constraint on future product behavior and public positioning.

Public boundary: This ADR publishes the judgment and product boundary while withholding exact prompts, routes, thresholds, schemas, tests, and other reproducible implementation details where applicable.

Confidence: Medium-high for public architecture; implementation details remain private and subject to launch evidence.

Timestamp

2026-07-17

C12-039Case #012 RegistryC12-041
Human captures. AI reads.benchantech.com · yymethod.com