YY markYY Method™ · Home Edition v2.3
MethodViolinCases & ADRsBen Chan
← Case Studies/Case #012/C12-038
C12-038DecidedDefensive Judgment and First ResponseFoundational2026-07-17

Narrow the Meaningful Action Surface

The app does not need to solve every problem.

Freshness
Permanent

Permanent. Revisit if launch evidence, teacher feedback, user behavior, corpus quality, or safety review materially changes this decision.

Dependencies

No dependencies — foundational anchor.

#defensive-judgment#narrow#violin-stand-partner

Capture

The app does not need to solve every problem.

Why

AI products often treat action generation as success.

In this architecture, non-action may be the highest-value result.

Why-Not

The rejected path would make narrow the Meaningful Action Surface too easy to treat as an implementation detail instead of a public boundary. The ADR preserves the tradeoff explicitly so later product work cannot silently widen authority.

Commit

Decision: The app does not need to solve every problem.

The app becomes protective rather than performatively helpful.


Confidence: Medium-high for public architecture; implementation details remain private and subject to launch evidence.

Timestamp

2026-07-17

C12-037Case #012 RegistryC12-039
Human captures. AI reads.benchantech.com · yymethod.com