Reject Automatic Transfer of Player Advice to Parents

Capture

The same physical instruction changes risk depending on:

• experience;
• familiarity with the instrument;
• emotional state;
• environmental conditions;
• instrument size;
• whether the user can identify relevant parts;
• whether a teacher has already authorized the action.

Advice suitable for a trained player cannot automatically be presented to a parent or novice helper.

Why

This decision matters because reject Automatic Transfer of Player Advice to Parents constrains the product toward continuity, evidence, and human judgment rather than broad AI helpfulness.

Why-Not

• exact actor-based branching;
• authorization thresholds;
• wording variants;
• routing priority order.

---

Commit

Decision: Advice suitable for a trained player cannot automatically be presented to a parent or novice helper.

The decision becomes a constraint on future product behavior and public positioning.

Public boundary: This ADR publishes the judgment and product boundary while withholding exact prompts, routes, thresholds, schemas, tests, and other reproducible implementation details where applicable.

Confidence: Medium-high for public architecture; implementation details remain private and subject to launch evidence.

Timestamp

2026-07-17